clock menu more-arrow no yes mobile

Filed under:

Montreal Impact’s Greatest-ever MLS-player - The Quarter Finals, Day 1

Some IMFC juggernauts in today’s action - Arnaud, Bernier, Di Vaio and Piatti...

Opponents now, team-mates then, DiVaio and Piatti celebrate a goal against CD Fas of El Saldor in Champions League play, 2014
Photo credit should read JOSE CABEZAS/AFP via Getty Images

So we reach the quarter final stages with three of the favourites still alive and very much kicking, although two of them come head to head in one of today’s big match-ups.

It’s of course the clash between Nacho Piatti most people’s favourite to prevail overall in the competition, and Marco Di Vaio. Piatti should overcome Di Vaio, although it won’t surprise if the contest is somewhat closer than the results in Piatti’s run to the quarter-finals. He’s polled 86% in the group stages and 88% in the round of 16. Di Vaio is likely to provide a sterner test, however it’s unlikely the Italian can win more votes than the Argentinian.

But Di Vaio’s percentages have been impressive also, topping his group with 74% and hitting 88% in his round of 16 clash with Justin Mapp, so you just never know.

It is probably close in many people’s minds. There will be those that side with Di Vaio for sentimental reasons and there can be all kinds of reasons why someone favours one player over another, but in a linear poll like this one marginal considerations don’t exist. It’s black and white, a ‘yes’ or a ‘no’ answer. So a large difference between the percentage scores may still occur even if fans are thinking that one player just shades it over the other.

SOCCER: JUN 21 Canadian Championship - Toronto FC at Montreal Impact
Patrice Bernier, a hot favourite to reach the semi-final, shows Jozy Altidore a clean pair of heels...
Photo by David Kirouac/Icon Sportswire via Getty Images

In the other quarter-final today, Patrice Bernier meets Davy Arnaud who squeezed through a dramatic round of 16 meeting with Bojan Krkic in which the lead changed hands several times. The American eventually prevailed, narrowly, with 52% of the vote, but now it gets even tougher in the battle of the first two IMFC MLS captains.

Bernier will assume the mantle of favourite for this one, after polling impressively in both the group and the round of 16, where his percentage vote shares were 67% and 83% respectively.

The winner of the Arnaud/Bernier quarter-final will face the winner of Bush/Donadel in the semi-final, while Piatti or Di Vaio faces the winner of the Oyongo/Taider quarter-final in the other semi-final.

Toronto FC v Montreal Impact
Davy Arnaud, up against it in facing Patrice Bernier in the quarter-final, seen here shielding the ball away from Terry Dunfield of Toronto FC in 2012
Photo by Richard Wolowicz/Getty Images


Quarter-final B

This poll is closed

  • 13%
    Davy Arnaud
    (12 votes)
  • 86%
    Patrice Bernier
    (78 votes)
90 votes total Vote Now


Quarter-final D

This poll is closed

  • 80%
    Ignacio Piatti
    (72 votes)
  • 20%
    Marco Di Vaio
    (18 votes)
90 votes total Vote Now